Submission of post-publication critique

You can submit a post-publication critique via this site.

As AME Publishing Company is a publisher member of Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), all AME journals’ post-publication discussion will be handled in accordance with the COPE Core practices for handling post-publication critique:

Besides, AME journals’ policy for managing allegations of research misconduct ( is based on the guidelines of the COPE, the World Association of Medical Editors (WAME), and the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE).

To balance potential conflicting factors, specification of a threshold must be met we will conduct investigation into the complaint. Elements of this threshold may include:

i. Identification of a specific, nontrivial act of potential professional critique during the research or publication process. Differences in professional opinion or disputes that are purely of a personal or legal nature are not within the purview of the journal’s investigation process.


*Your name:

*Your affiliation:

*Contact email:

Conflicts of interest with the concerned manuscript (if any, please refer to:

*Article title:

*Published journal:
*Article link:

*Specification of the allegation:

*For investigation, your queries/critique may be forwarded to the authors of the concerned paper or to related research institution. Your personal identify will be masked but we are not sure if the queries/critique wording may accidentally reveal your identity. Please confirm if you would like to proceed or not:

Upload of related documents (if any):
No File Selected
Copyright © 2009 - AME Publishing Company. All Rights Reserved.